let me pick your brains

Posted: Tue May 22, 2018 1:36 pm

i have a couple of roll ups here that i could use some opinions on.

10-12-8-16-8-3-13--->13-12-8-21-9-4-17 or 11-13-8-21-11-3-17. ST/AB/PR i would really like a PR outta this one as i have ran many ST's and AB's designed this way. I have never ran a PS, would this make a good one??

10-15-10-11-12-7-5--->11-17-10-17-17-7-5 TP. 13-15-10-17-17-7-5, 11-15-10-17-17-7-7. My first thought was the TP. my normal way of thinking would be the second set of numbers as a ST/LU but it seems that is a waste of CN and it really doesnt help much on offensives as they still get taken out in a couple of shots. I would appreciate any knowledge and insight you guys are willing to let me pick your brain for.

Posted: Tue May 22, 2018 2:30 pm

10-12-8-16-8-3-13:
If I was going PR, I'd go 15-14-8-21-8-3-15 PR. That said, I wouldn't use this on a PR. 29% chance at normal damage kills that option for me. I won't run PR's unless they have good damage. Taking a 21 wit and giving me about a 1/3 chance to throw it away doesn't seem like a good use.

I'd probably go 15-12-8-21-8-3-17 AB on this one. If I didn't want an AB, 15-16-8-21-8-3-13 TP/WS

The second looks like:
11-15-10-17-17-7-7 LU to me. I might go BA on it, but I'd also expect to be DAing him soon.

Posted: Tue May 22, 2018 2:42 pm

I completely disagree with Assur on the first one. I totally go PR with your numbers 13-12-8-21-9-4-17 PR

The second one I like your second LU design.

Posted: Tue May 22, 2018 5:21 pm

gentleben wrote:

I completely disagree with Assur on the first one. I totally go PR with your numbers 13-12-8-21-9-4-17 PR

The second one I like your second LU design.

This one 11-15-10-17-17-7-7 LU

Posted: Wed May 23, 2018 2:09 am

jack wrote:

i have a couple of roll ups here that i could use some opinions on.

10-12-8-16-8-3-13--->13-12-8-21-9-4-17 or 11-13-8-21-11-3-17. ST/AB/PR i would really like a PR outta this one as i have ran many ST's and AB's designed this way. I have never ran a PS, would this make a good one??

10-15-10-11-12-7-5--->11-17-10-17-17-7-5 TP. 13-15-10-17-17-7-5, 11-15-10-17-17-7-7. My first thought was the TP. my normal way of thinking would be the second set of numbers as a ST/LU but it seems that is a waste of CN and it really doesnt help much on offensives as they still get taken out in a couple of shots. I would appreciate any knowledge and insight you guys are willing to let me pick your brain for.

If we are making #1 a ripper, we agree with Assur's damage comment and we make it 15-15-8-21-9-3-13. There is no reason why your designs would not make a good to decent piker also. But once again, that damage issue comes to play, so we go the 15/15 route for a piker also. We would probably make another style with this RU, but there you have our advice on a needed ripper or piker.

#2 -sure it will make a solid TP - ours would look like 14-19-10-17-7-5 as we usually add only to WL, CN, ST for a scum. Comments CN is seldom wasted on a lunger. On RUs like this, we almost always take the 17/17 and work from there; hence, we go your 13/15 route and probably make it another basher in honor of Assur.